Why is Civil War a talking point?

Sunday 19 October, 15:45—17:00, Hoare Memorial Hall, Church HousePolitics

Partners:

Civil war in Britain is ‘inevitable’, prophesised Elon Musk after riots broke out following the Southport murders last summer. While we’ve yet to see tanks in Whitehall, there’s certainly a great deal of tension in the air.

Headlines warn of a ‘powder keg of tensions and grievances’ and caution we’re ‘lurching towards civil war, and nobody knows how to stop it’.  A new government commission on cohesion rings alarm bells over ‘creeping balkanisation and extremism’ while Lisa Nandy predicts Labour’s northern heartlands ‘could go up in flames’. A YouGov survey suggests that a third of the public now believe civil war is likely to occur in Britain within the next 10 years.

David Betz, professor of war in the modern world and Ministry of Defence adviser, says Britain may already be in a ‘cold civil war’, brought about by a combination of elites devoid of national unifying ideals, along with cultural, ethnic and ideological splintering and a status reversal of previously dominant groups. By contrast to past conflicts over territory conducted by ordered forces of uniformed troops, this struggle is over identity, legitimacy and the moral basis of the state. Betz fears ‘feral cities’ where infrastructure sabotage fuels the collapse of services like power, food and connectivity, and justifies a surveillance society and enforced no-go zones.

Sceptics say talk of civil war is overhyped. Yes, societal divisions have grown, but unhinged claims aimed at standing out in today’s ultracompetitive attention economy simply fuel doomscrolling. After the ‘Sophie of Dundee’ video of a girl brandishing an axe at a migrant went viral – creating a false but lurid narrative of a battle against predatory hordes – one commentator asked: ‘What choice do the Sophies of that soul-sick nation have but to arm themselves?’

Ironically, talking up the inevitability of civil war leaves the political right open to the charge of apocalyptic doom-mongering often levelled at left-leaning opponents. Where climate-change fanatics promote a world consumed by heatwaves and flooded cities, the right seem convinced that we’re but a few years from social breakdown and street battles. Critics of Civil War, Alex Garland’s Hollywood take on the issue in America, derided the film as catastrophe porn. Are claims of civil war now being used to stoke overblown fears in the same way environmentalists utilised apocalypticism to political advantage?

To what extent is the civil-war thesis a useful attempt to explore the material reality of social fragmentation today? How do we get the balance right between valuable insights and excessive fearmongering – and are critics right to worry that catastrophism risks escalating tensions? But if talk of civil war is overstated, then why does it increasingly feel like we’re preparing for one?