What should schools teach about sex and relationships?
Successive governments have struggled with Relationships, Sex and Health Education (RSHE). But in July, the Department for Education finally published the long-anticipated guidance to schools to a mixed reception. Some critics argue that crucial safeguards made by the Conservatives have been watered down by Labour.
Giving parents access to classroom materials has dominated the discussion in recent years, both in the news and the courts. The new guidance claims that parents will be able to see what their children are being taught, but concerns remain about how this will work in practice.
Transparency is only one aspect of this emotive and divisive topic. Other conflicts between so-called ‘conservative’ and ‘progressive’ parents include whether these controversial classes are compulsory and, most importantly, what, when and how they are taught, and by whom.
This RSHE guidance is not to be confused with the separate Gender Questioning Children guidance, which will outline how schools should treat kids who say they are trans. The government has announced that this must be published by the time the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act passes into law. But with so much debate on the highly contested concept of gender identity, how can we possibly explain it to our kids?
Even among parents, teachers and commentators who are sceptical about transgenderism, there is no consensus on the broader aspects of sex and relationship education. Should we be teaching teenagers about consent and coercion, masturbation and misogyny, spiking and surrogacy – and what, if anything, should teachers and external providers be telling primary school children about sex?
Should we let kids be kids, leave it to Biology teachers to explain the basics and for parents to decide what they discuss in their family about intimacy? Or do we need to ensure that children are educated about all the potential offline and online dangers that young people face?





