School’s out: the rise of home education

Saturday 18 October, 13:45—14:30, Temple Room, Church HouseBattle for the Classroom

Partners:

The number of children being home schooled is rising rapidly and the government is cracking down. Until now, the law recognised that it is not school, but education that is mandatory, and parents have been trusted to decide on the best options for their own children.

Currently, there are no restrictions on parents taking their children out of, or never sending them to, school. However, this is set to change with the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill and many home-schooling parents argue this amounts to state over-reach.

This Bill was announced on the same day as the sentencing of the father and stepmother of 10-year-old Sara Sharif, who took her out of school to hide the unthinkable abuse that led to her death. Supporters of the Bill ask what is wrong with a law change to protect children. Who can object to parents no longer having an automatic right to home educate if their child is subject to a child protection investigation or under a child protection plan?

But critics of the Bill argue that the inference that home-schooling is, in itself, a safeguarding issue is an insult to parents. In Sara Sharif’s case, the issue was not home schooling but state agencies placing her with a known abuser. What’s more, plans to introduce compulsory Children Not in School registers in every local authority in England, so that councils can make sure that all children are receiving a suitable education, are over-intrusive, undermine privacy and create a culture of mistrust in parents’ freedom to educate their own children.

Why do parents increasingly decide to home educate? According to government research, the main reason has always been philosophical beliefs. Certainly, the freedom not to have to follow the national curriculum is appealing to those parents who worry lessons have become politicised around race, climate change and gender. For example, sex and relationships education has been used to push gender ideology onto children.

But also, after Covid, children’s mental health has been the fastest-growing reason given by parents for taking their children out of school. Bullying, special educational needs, religious beliefs and general dissatisfaction with local schools and lack of places are also often cited. Some believe that the tax raid on private schools will only increase this trend and there have even been reports of parents removing their children from school to avoid term-time holiday fines.

Should parents have the freedom to educate their children as they wish, without state interference? Will these new measures prevent vulnerable children falling through the cracks and provide vital safeguarding for those most at risk? Who should be responsible for children – their parents or the state?