An island of strangers? Immigration and integration
In May 2025, Prime Minister Keir Starmer delivered a speech unveiling Labour’s plans to curb net migration. It framed high migration levels as a ‘failed experiment’ by the previous Conservative government, arguing it not only strained public services, but community cohesion, too. While controversial with many of his own supporters, Starmer’s statement that ‘in a diverse nation like ours… we risk becoming an island of strangers, not a nation that walks forward together’ landed with many more ordinary voters.
In the wake of a subsequent backlash, Starmer expressed ‘deep regret’ for that wording. But actually, his ‘island of strangers’ phrase resonated with huge swathes of the public. It cut through because millions experience an intense feeling of estrangement daily. Many say they don’t recognise their own neighbourhoods and feel overwhelmed by the huge surge in newcomers to the country, whether arriving legally or illegally.
This contrasts with the past, when Britain oversaw tens of thousands of migrants arriving from its own former colonies in the West Indies or South Asia, all under a common citizenship. Many of these newcomers identified with Britain, and despite pockets of racism, willingly assimilated themselves.
But unprecedented numbers arriving in recent years make that approach seem unmanageable. And politically, the notion of a common culture is portrayed as backward and parochial. British citizens are constantly told to repudiate their collective traditions and history by those who Professor James Orr calls ‘rootless, cosmopolitical ideologues’, too often leading to competing identity groups living parallel lives. The loss of a commitment to common norms, a sense of belonging and a collective national story – one that could integrate new arrivals into a united nation of many strangers – is now under strain.
Some commentators are worried about the emergence of Fortress Britain. A recent front page New Statesman essay worried that we are being propelled ‘out of an age of migration into something altogether new: an age of deportation’. What’s more, the demand to deport ever greater numbers seem to be unsettling our historic views of citizenship. The Windrush generation were considered by the vast majority as British, no ifs or buts. Now some – albeit a minority – are arguing that even if they were born here or held British citizenship, even second- and third-generation migrants should be treated essentially as foreigners who could legitimately be deported.
Is the immigration debate – which may be motivated by a reasonable demand to control our borders and streets – spiralling towards darker sentiments? Is immigration really the reason for feelings of estrangement? Does that explain why so many people plan to vote Reform or attended the Unite the Kingdom march? Are migrants being scapegoated for broader reasons that the country seems so ill at ease with itself or for why people feel fed up with being ignored, powerless, disconnected, estranged?






