Damsels in distress? The women’s safety dilemma

Sunday 19 October, 15:45—17:00, Robert Runcie Room, Church HouseWomen's Freedom

Women’s safety is certainly making headlines. The gross abuses of the grooming rape gangs have revealed a huge state cover-up of sexual abuse in myriad towns and cities in the UK.  The rise of the Canary Wharf Pink Ladies focuses on concerns about threats to women and girls from young, asylum-seeking men housed in local hotels. One group argues that ‘women are being harassed, dismissed, and dehumanised and no one’s listening. The immigration policies over the past decade have made Britain more unsafe.’ Meanwhile, many gender-critical activists campaign on the safety threat of allowing biological men, who identify as women, to use female facilities, whether it is changing rooms, toilets or prisons.

Surrey Police’s Undercover Jogger campaign – aimed at ensnaring cat callers (arguably a pre-crime entrapment policy) – is justified in the name of protecting women from harassment and sexual assault.  Violence against women and girls (VAWG) initiatives have been flagship campaigns for both Conservative and Labour governments and are increasingly embraced by a wide variety of institutions.

But some warn that there may be dangers in creating a narrative which portrays women as under siege from male perpetrators, of creating a culture of fear in which catcalling and rape are assumed to be part of the same misogynist spectrum. Hasn’t such fear been historically used to deny women access to the public square, told to stay at home rather than going out for the night, just in case? It is less than a century ago that women were kept away from workplaces, demonstrations, football terraces, universities, parliament and pubs – for their own safety. In some cultures, such as the Taliban’s Afghanistan, such attitudes about extraordinary measures used to ‘protect’ the ‘weaker sex’ prevail with brutal consequences.

Scaremongering about safety, with all the tropes of damsels who need to be protected, has traditionally been used as a tool to deny women freedom and equality. But is risk-averse fearmongering playing into the hands of male aggression and disempowering women? As Ella Whelan argues: ‘When sexist men behave like pigs… what they are doing is asserting their power and dominance over what they believe to be an afraid woman. This means that the only way to really fight back is for women to refuse to be painted as constantly in fear.’

How do we avoid succumbing to safetyism writ large, the idea that women need someone watching over them in order to go about their daily lives?  Is there a balance between campaigns for policies that will enhance women’s safety and avoiding infantilising women as perpetual victims? Is a general culture of fear in danger of marginalising women’s agency and giving power to the authorities? Or do the warrior women associated with groups such as the Pink Ladies or Let Women Speak, taking action autonomously, counter any idea of weakness or cowering?