Are human rights scuppering democracy?
A particular brand of legalism seems to exist at the heart of government today. Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s background is as a human-rights lawyer and his controversial attorney general, Lord Hermer, has declared that he will veto any government decision that he deems illegal.
Meanwhile, the media have started to document the use of human-rights laws to block the deportation of the worst foreign criminals by granting asylum status to the most unlikely applicants. For example, an immigration tribunal concluded that it would be ‘unduly harsh’ and a breach of a son’s human right to family life for his father, a Pakistani drug dealer, to be deported.
Yet in the aftermath of the Second World War, the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) was seen as a protection against the tyranny and oppression that some European nations had recently endured. Nowadays, those who support the ECHR and its court in Strasbourg stress the importance of human rights as setting a minimum standard that democracy must guarantee.
In 2000, the Human Rights Act (HRA) made the ECHR an integral part of domestic law, that individuals could enforce in British courts. Since then, many, particularly on the political right, have questioned the wisdom of a convention that is seen to have suffered from ‘mission creep’. Instead of protecting democracy, its critics now criticise those many lawyers who make a living from deploying human rights as hostile to common sense and the public will.
Supporters object that human rights should not be seen simply through the prism of contentious issues such as immigration. They argue that human rights has been invaluable in defending our rights, such as the free-speech rights of gender-critical feminists, in the fight for equal treatment of women, and in fending off state surveillance over-reach. In August, for example, the Metropolitan Police’s plan to use live facial-recognition technology at Notting Hill Carnival was ruled to be in breach of human-rights laws.
Lord Hermer said recently: ‘I’d like to be very clear: the new UK government will never withdraw from the ECHR.’ But as increasing numbers of commentators note, for the government to deliver on its increasingly bold policy announcements on illegal migration, law and order, and prison reform, it will need to defy human-rights conventions.
In any event, is ‘leave the ECHR’ a silver bullet that is more rhetorical than practical? If Britain withdrew from the ECHR, and even if it were replaced with a British Bill of Rights that tried to enhance democracy, could it become just a rebranded vehicle for human-rights orthodoxies, especially if the attitudes of today’s lawyers and judiciary remain unchallenged?
So, are human rights good or bad for democracy? Is the problem not with human rights themselves, but with overreach from a European body, the Council of Europe, which oversees the ECHR? Have ‘lefty lawyers’ been given too much of a free hand to shape human-rights law in a ‘progressive’ political direction at the expense of British culture, values and interests? Is the real problem that cowardly politicians are happy for lawyers to take the flak for decisions they quietly agree with? In a wider context, would dumping human rights remove important protections on free speech, privacy, the right to protest and individual liberty?




