Contempt of court: protecting the innocent or stifling debate?

Sunday 19 October, 12:45—13:30, Temple Room, Church HouseLaw and disorder

Contempt of court has traditionally been respected as crucial to justice and fair trials. Even the most ardent free-speech absolutists respect not speaking out if comments might prejudice legal proceedings in criminal cases or not publishing information that could unfairly influence a trial. But over the past year or so, contempt of court rules have become the centre of some heated public controversies over political and media censorship, while their usefulness is queried in a social-media era.

For example, last summer, the public were told that court laws prevented the police, politicians and the media from revealing details about Axel Rudakubana, the man later charged with the brutal murders of three young girls in Stockport. In light of public uproar, this has now been addressed via interim guidance from the National Police Chiefs’ Council (NPCC). But a trend for withholding information about suspects – whether ethnicity or details of charges – in order to prevent a prejudiced jury, has seen the police and politicians accused of trying to contain political disquiet rather than ensure a fair trial.

In May last year, the New Yorker published a 13,000-word article by Rachel Aviv, which questioned the safety of the conviction of Lucy Letby. Cheshire Constabulary reported the article to the Attorney General’s Office suspecting it breached the Contempt of Court Act. Penalties for breaching this can include unlimited fines, trial collapse and imprisonment of editors or journalists. The piece was then ‘geoblocked’ and not available to people in the UK, on the basis it could influence jurors in Letby’s retrial, despite the anomaly of the article’s availability in print.

On both occasions, these laws led to an information vacuum in which misinformation, counternarratives and claims of cover ups could spread unchecked. In the case of Stockport, this at least contributed in part to a period of widespread civil unrest.

Fast forward to 2025 and other widely covered cases – such as the shooting of Chris Kaba and the assaults on police at Manchester Airport – have brought contempt of court laws into question. These can also include ignoring a court order, as in the case of Tommy Robinson, who was jailed for 18 months after admitting 10 breaches of a High Court injunction that barred him from repeating false allegations.

Some argue the law is outdated, as global online access undermines restrictions. During Letby’s original trial and retrial, online forums, social media and blogs extensively discussed the case, often breaching legal restrictions. Despite the law, Robinson’s film, Silenced, was shared to tens of millions globally via online platforms.

What is contempt of court and why does it exist? With the Law Commission currently reviewing the rules to improve their ‘effectiveness, consistency and coherence’, what will they be looking at? Should free speech be a consideration? How far should and could the Law Commission go? With even the staunchest defenders of the 1981 Act conceding that it has not kept pace with the digital world, is it finally time for a reboot?